Uploaded image for project: 'Couchbase Server'
  1. Couchbase Server
  2. MB-31556

Complex N1QL "Group By" Fails with "Duplicate Final Group" Error

    XMLWordPrintable

Details

    • Bug
    • Resolution: Fixed
    • Major
    • 6.5.0
    • 5.5.0
    • query
    • None
    • Untriaged
    • Unknown

    Description

      I have some date (from Support's Nutshell) an array of nested objects.

      When I run a query to extract distinct values from one field of those nested objects:

      select array_distinct(array_star(array_star(array_star(node).results).checkers).`OS Name`)[0] as os, count(*) as os_count 
      from nutshell 
      where array_length(array_distinct(array_star(array_star(array_star(node).results).checkers).`OS Name`)) > 0 
      group by array_distinct(array_star(array_star(array_star(node).results).checkers).`OS Name`)[0];

      I get the following error:

      {{[ { "code": 5040, "msg": "Duplicate Final Group." } ] }}

       

      If I rename the "Group By" using "Let", however, the query works fine:

      select os, count(*) as count 
      from nutshell 
      LET os = array_distinct(array_star(array_star(array_star(node).results).checkers).`OS Name`)[0] 
      where array_length(array_distinct(array_star(array_star(array_star(node).results).checkers).`OS Name`)) > 0 
      group by os;

       

      I would expect these two queries to be equivalent, but one of them fails.

       

      FYI, the "node" subobject appears as follows:

            "node": [
              {
                "node": "ns_1@127.0.0.1",
                "results": {
                  "analysers": {
                    "Open File Information": {
                      "Command": [
                        "beam.smp",
                        "memcached",
                        "moxi",
                        "==Total=="
                      ],
                      "File Descriptors": [
                        "74",
                        "202",
                        "46",
                        "328"
                      ],
                      "Memory Maps": [
                        "40",
                        "22",
                        "18",
                        "84"
                      ]
                    },
                    "Per Node Bucket Stats (CB buckets only)": {
                      "Active": "-",
                      "Bucket": "Total (0 buckets)",
                      "Current Items": "0",
                      "In-Memory KV (MB)": "0",
                      "Metadata %": "-",
                      "Replica": "0",
                      "Resident Ratio": "-"
                    }
                  },
                  "checkers": {
                    "CB Packages": "ii couchbase-server 3.1.6 Couchbase Server",
                    "CB Uptime": "??? (Attribute not found). Cannot check.",
                    "CB Version": "3.1.6-1904-rel-enterprise - EOL Version",
                    "Collection Time": "2017-07-04 02:21:08",
                    "Data Directory": "/opt/couchbase/var/lib/couchbase/data - ext4 - (/dev/sdb1 1.1TB / 1% used)",
                    "Data Quota": 77221,
                    "Dedupe NMVB Maps": "Disabled",
                    "Erlang VM vsize": 2078,
                    "Installed CPUs": 40,
                    "Installed RAM": 128702,
                    "Interface 'bond0' MTU": "uses Jumbo Frames MTU value 9000",
                    "Interface 'bond0' failures": "RX:363116 / TX:0 - Details:\n        - RX packets:739,726  errors:0  dropped:363,116  overruns:0  frame:0 ",
                    "Interface 'eth0' MTU": "uses Jumbo Frames MTU value 9000",
                    "Interface 'eth0' failures": "RX:363103 / TX:0 - Details:\n        - RX packets:362,638  errors:0  dropped:363,103  overruns:0  frame:0 ",
                    "Interface 'eth1' MTU": "uses Jumbo Frames MTU value 9000",
                    "Interface 'eth1' failures": "RX:0 / TX:0",
                    "Interface 'eth2' Status": "down",
                    "Interface 'eth3' Status": "down",
                    "Interface 'vlan330' (172.20.19.66) failures": "RX:117 / TX:0 - Details:\n        - RX packets:298,533  errors:0  dropped:117  overruns:0  frame:0 ",
                    "Interface 'vlan330' MTU": "uses Jumbo Frames MTU value 9000",
                    "Memcached Fragmentation": "??? (Attribute not found). Cannot check.",
                    "Memcached vsize": 395,
                    "NUMA Configuration": "2 nodes - Couchbase processes have default NUMA policy",
                    "OS Name": "Linux 3.13.0-32-generic",
                    "OS Version": "Ubuntu 12.04.5 LTS",
                    "Swap Used": {
                      "total": 28762108,
                      "used": 0
                    },
                    "System Uptime": "23 min",
                    "Total Server Quota": 77221,
                    "Transparent Huge Pages": "always - Recommended is 'never' or 'madvise'",
                    "Used RAM": {
                      "total": 128701,
                      "used": 1610
                    },
                    "analyse_connections": "Failed to run analyser",
                    "check_non_default_max_connections": "Failed to run checker",
                    "vm.swappiness": "0 (Recommended value)"
                  }
                }
              }
            ],
       

      Attachments

        No reviews matched the request. Check your Options in the drop-down menu of this sections header.

        Activity

          People

            keshav Keshav Murthy
            eben Eben Haber
            Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            Watchers:
            3 Start watching this issue

            Dates

              Created:
              Updated:
              Resolved:

              Gerrit Reviews

                There are no open Gerrit changes

                PagerDuty