Uploaded image for project: 'Couchbase Server'
  1. Couchbase Server
  2. MB-4896

moxi mem leak when using haproxy roundrobin load-balancing



      Can't find the exact bug for this (other bugs also mention moxi memory leak, and might be the same, but they don't mention haproxy).

      Reproduced this customer reported issue, and there's a quick config workaround that can slow the leak.

      More info:

      After spinning up a 20 node cluster, with haproxy, valgrind, and a special debug build of moxi, using a configuration similar to XXX's, I was able to reproduce a significant memory leak in moxi. It occurs during topology changes, or, when moxi thinks there's a cluster topology change. Other customers probably never noticed, since topology changes are usually infrequent.

      Additionally, XXX's use of haproxy, in roundrobin load-balancing configuration significantly exacerbated the bug/leak in moxi. (I recall Tim had another report of a moxi mem leak from another customer. Perhaps they're also using haproxy?)

      Here's XXX's haproxy configuration...

      log local2
      chroot /var/lib/haproxy
      pidfile /var/run/haproxy.pid
      maxconn 4000
      user haproxy
      group haproxy

      mode http
      log global
      option dontlognull
      option httpclose
      option httplog
      option forwardfor
      timeout connect 10000
      timeout client 300000
      timeout server 300000
      maxconn 60000
      retries 3
      stats enable
      stats uri /haproxy-status
      stats refresh 5s

      frontend moxi *:8092
      default_backend moxi

      backend moxi
      balance roundrobin
      server node1 check
      server node2 check
      server node3 check
      server node4 check
      server node5 check
      server node6 check
      server node7 check
      server node8 check
      server node9 check
      server node10 check
      server node11 check
      server node12 check
      server node13 check
      server node14 check
      server node15 check
      server node16 check
      server node17 check
      server node18 check

      The workaround to reduce the leak includes...

      = change from haproxy's 'balance roundrobin' to some other load balancing choice.

      For example, when I instead used 'balance source' instead of 'balance roundrobin' in my haproxy configuration, the leak went away. (Caveat: it went away until I did an actual real topology change.)

      The underlying issue is moxi's doing a simple string comparison to decide whether the topology has changed. And, every node in a cluster gives a slightly different answer as to the topology. When moxi thinks the topology has changed, moxi will tear-down its data structures and dynamically reconfigure, and there's a leak there somewhere.

      Normally, moxi, expects its HTTP/REST connection to be very long lived. However, when haproxy's in the middle, the haproxy might decide to timeout a HTTP connection that's still open but hasn't been doing anything. (e.g, the HTTP/REST connection hasn't been doing anything because there's no topology change). This leads to the second haproxy config workaround suggestion...

      = increase haproxy's timeouts

      XXX's currently using 5 minute timeouts (in millisecs)...

      timeout client 300000
      timeout server 300000

      So, every 5 minutes, haproxy times out the connection and closes it. moxi sees the closed HTTP/REST connection and tries again. haproxy will choose the next server node on its list (since haproxy is in 'balance roundrobin' configuration). That next server node will return a slightly different topology answer. Then moxi (because it's doing simple string comparison) will inadvertently think the topology configuration has changed (when it actually hasn't), exposing the leak.

      This was with haproxy 1.4.20.

      No reviews matched the request. Check your Options in the drop-down menu of this sections header.


        steve Steve Yen created issue -
        steve Steve Yen made changes -
        Field Original Value New Value
        Status Open [ 1 ] Resolved [ 5 ]
        Resolution Fixed [ 1 ]
        farshid Farshid Ghods (Inactive) made changes -
        Labels 1.7.0-release-notes 1.7.1-release-notes 1.7.2-release-notes 1.8.0-release-notes
        dipti Dipti Borkar made changes -
        Fix Version/s 1.8.1 [ 10295 ]
        farshid Farshid Ghods (Inactive) made changes -
        Labels 1.7.0-release-notes 1.7.1-release-notes 1.7.2-release-notes 1.8.0-release-notes 1.7.0-release-notes 1.7.1-release-notes 1.7.2-release-notes 1.8.0-release-notes 1.8.1-release-notes
        maria Maria McDuff (Inactive) made changes -
        Fix Version/s 2.0-beta [ 10113 ]
        Fix Version/s 1.8.2 [ 10249 ]
        Fix Version/s 1.8.1 [ 10295 ]


          • Assignee:
            steve Steve Yen
            steve Steve Yen
          • Votes:
            0 Vote for this issue
            0 Start watching this issue


            • Created:

              Gerrit Reviews

              There are no open Gerrit changes